December 11, 2007
You know I’m something of a book addict. My mother actually calls it that, says it’s my addiction. I say, at least I’m not a crackhead. But you know what else I’m addicted to? Television. Yes, that’s right, the girl who wants to read 365 books in a year has also got her DVR set to record eleven different television shows every week, and those are just the regular prime-time series. There are also reruns and marathons and the occasional movie and other things. (And, as you can imagine, the writers’ strike is rather distressing to me!).
My mother made a comment the other day. She said, “I’m really surprised that someone who loves books as much as you do is also so addicted to TV!”
I’m not. Honestly, to me, they’re not so different. No matter how much people say that TV rots your brain and books make you smarter…I don’t see it that way. I guess it all depends how you watch TV; brainlessly staring at Road Runner cartoons for six hours on a Saturday like my brother does may not be doing so much for his brain. But following actual stories? To me, it’s a lot like reading. You’re following a story, you’re learning from what the characters go through (both in terms of learning a lesson and just learning background-information facts). If you’re me, you’re critiquing both the story and the way the piece itself was done (costumes, acting, cinematography), you’re speculating about what would happen next, and if your brain doesn’t feel busy enough you create new episodes in your head, change events and see how the outcome would change, move characters from different shows around and see how they’d react, how their presence would change the show, even put book characters in the TV (including characters from my own writing)…Okay, maybe I have a more active imagination than most people. Or so I’m told. The point is, TV isn’t a passive experience for me, anymore than books are. In fact I might even think more sometimes, because on TV I’m considering the set, the acting, the soundtrack, the costumes, etc., along with the story itself and its value. In a book, I’m mostly considering the value of the story. Neither one is passive!
One could argue that book stories are better because you’re learning vocabulary and grammar and everything. And, yes, I think that’s important and I’m not saying one should exclusively watch television and not read books. But who says you can’t do both? TV has value, too, it just doesn’t lie in better writing skills. Well, I should say it doesn’t lie in becoming more proficient in the mechanics of writing. But you do learn about how to construct a story, I think. And how stories differ when you’re putting them in the pages of a book and several seasons of a television show!
But they’re both stories. And while I do love words, what I really love are good stories. In that regard, TV and books aren’t so different!
*Yeah, that’s my second ramble of the day, but I’ll be back to posting some reviews (back to your regularly scheduled programming) soon. *
December 12, 2007 at 12:13 pm
Oh, I agree! I love TV. I like books a thousand times more, but I usually watch about six shows a week. And the occasional movie or rerun of Gilmore Girls (best show ever!)
But those are some good points you made.
December 12, 2007 at 1:52 pm
I agree. There’s only about 4 TV shows I watch all the time, but I enjoy absolutely evey minute of them!
December 12, 2007 at 7:49 pm
This post was really thought-provoking - thanks for the insights. I’m addicted to Grey’s Anatomy and some of my friends tease me and say that it’s just a soap opera. But recently I found out that each episode has a corresponding “theme song” and the atmosphere of the episode supposedly mirrors the lyrics of the song. So if you have that in mind while watching, it’s definitely not a passive activity! :)
December 16, 2007 at 7:25 pm
Just chiming in to say: I love TV. Basically, I love good stories, whether its a book or TV. And you also totally nailed it when you said, watching TV isn’t a passive activity.
And for what its worth — many of the readers I know are also fans of TV!
March 14, 2008 at 9:01 pm
[...] all been told that screens are rotting our brains. You’ve read about why I don’t think movies and television are at all brain-rotting, even the supposedly trashy TV shows. The same goes for the internet, but even more [...]
April 17, 2008 at 2:36 pm
[...] a fantastic movie, and, well, a fantastic movie and a fantastic book have a lot in common. Great stories can be found on both screens and pages! This is my justification for talking about a movie on a book blog, but, in all honesty, I think [...]
May 26, 2008 at 9:22 pm
[...] my defense of my television addiction here. Posted by jocelyn Filed in [...]